Read the transcript
Jeroen Leenarts: Welcome to
another special episode of my
podcast. I'm sitting here with
Josh Holtz. And most people will
know him from his work of
Fastlane tools. But there's a
lot of other things that he also
works on. And probably also a
lot of things that we don't know
about him. First of all, the
most important thing right now
is congratulations on your son.
Thank you very much. How are you
hanging in there, George?
Josh Holtz: I'm doing I'm doing
good. I mean, I'm, I'm awake
right now. I've learned to get a
little bit of less sleep and
sleep when I can. It's kind of
been a pretty drastic change.
But it's super fun so far.
Totally worth it.
Jeroen Leenarts: So this is your
first public appearance that you
did after the birth or?
Josh Holtz: Yes, this is
actually the first time I'm also
at my home office in over a
month, I've been sat in this
chair since beginning of
December. So it's a little bit
foreign and also a mess.
Jeroen Leenarts: Not probably
not as messy as things will get
when when your son gets older.
Josh Holtz: I guess this is this
is so true.
Jeroen Leenarts: So um, yeah,
just Congratulations again. And
how are things in the US where
you live?
Josh Holtz: Um, I've been trying
to ignore a lot of stuff that's
been going on, especially
politically, because it's, it's
all a mess right now. But we
have snow outside. And I like
snow. So that's nice.
Jeroen Leenarts: That's really
cool, actually. So yeah, I know
what you're referring to let's,
let's hope that January passes
by really quickly, and then
onwards to better and more
relaxing things politically.
Josh Holtz: I sure hope so. So,
Jeroen Leenarts: um, just to get
things started, people know you
from Fastlane tools, most
likely. But I think it's
actually an interesting story,
how you actually wound up at
Fastlane tools as as the lead on
that project. So can you tell a
little bit about that how you
actually got started on Fastlane
tools. And once we did that,
we'll dive a little bit deeper
in your history before Fastlane
tools as well.
Josh Holtz: Yeah, sounds good.
So I started a software
consulting firm, with a few
friends after school that have
been like fall of 2011. I took I
took a corporate enterprise job
after I graduated in May of
2011. And I stayed there for
exactly like two months, I
absolutely hated it. Like I was
actually did like no programming
the entire time there. And I'm
like, this isn't this is not
fun. So I wanted to go into
freelancing on my own. And I was
interested in mobile at the
time, any sort of platform, I
didn't really care. And then a
few of my friends also didn't
like their corporate jobs. So
they also wanted out. So we
started the consulting firm, I
was the first time or the first
person full time, because I quit
my job really quickly. And when
I got full of work, another guy
did work at night. And then when
he was too full at night, he
joined full time, I mean, kind
of like cascaded into five of us
being full time, within about
nine months. And we did all our
different kind of software
consulting stuff. I was mainly
mobile, but we kind of took
whatever work we could get at
the time, front end, web, back
end, whatever came in a lot of
Ruby back end, I don't even know
what kind of front end we did
the time when we might have done
like CoffeeScript stuff that
isn't really done much these
days anymore.
Jeroen Leenarts: JavaScript
changes every week, right? I
haven't touched it much
Josh Holtz: in like the past
three or four years, but I can't
keep up. It's, it's insane. So I
was mainly doing mobile. And we
had quite a few small clients at
the time. And a lot of my, a lot
of my time was actually getting
spent on building releasing app
store stuff across Android iOS,
like I was probably managing,
like for mobile apps and then or
for clients, different
platforms. And like my full time
job was just releasing stuff,
which felt insane. And then I
wasn't super active on Twitter,
but I luckily came across a
tweet from orda about Felix, who
was doing something like cool,
it was like it wasn't very
specific what he was doing. And
I was like, okay, like I kind of
interested in like, new things
happening. And then it turns out
it was exactly the the tools I
needed to help what I was doing
at work. So I ended up I think
my my first fast line pull
requests were actually into
snapshot for taking screenshots.
And the PRS that I made. Felix
liked it a lot of like,
descriptions screenshots
explaining what was happening
and invited to be on the core
team in January of 2015. Which
that's when Fastlane was still
owned fully by Felix. And each
tool was a separate gem, which
kind of was a disaster to
maintain. But that was like
forever ago. So I started using
Fastlane a lot in for our client
work. And then it turned out
that clients actually wanted
like their CI stuff done. So I
started doing consulting for CI
stuff, I became doing less
mobile building and more like
scripting and, and that kind of
stuff. So that was, that was
fun. Like, I actually got me to
contribute more, since I was
doing a lot of that pretty much
full time. And then, so I was
pretty active as a core
contributor for three, three ish
years, but I wasn't, I wasn't
like, super at the top. And then
in 2008 2017, to 2018, there was
another fast and related project
that wasn't like Fastlane
proper, that Felix was working
on. And he needed somebody to
actually main chain it or
maintain the core part. So he
brought me on as lead maintainer
of Fastlane, and beginning of
2018. And at that time, I was
still doing consulting, so I was
a lead maintainer, pretty much
like mornings, nights and
weekends, while doing consulting
during the day. So it became
became a lot of work. But it was
something that I thoroughly
enjoyed, since like, this is
like my ideal project, to, to
do. And then let's see where so
that was 2018. I was doing that
for two years, kind of on the
side morning nights. And then
luckily, I was able to get
funded to work on Fastlane, full
time as of July of 2020, which
was this past year. And that has
been like a dream come true. So
I gained a lot more free time, a
lot more brain space. And I got
a lot more done, I think in
those six months than what I did
in that in the previous two
years. So that's kind of my
Fastlane story, right there.
Jeroen Leenarts: You mentioned
that you you started the
consultant thing, like after two
months of corporate work. And
but what did you do before that
because you didn't computer
science education or something?
Yeah. So
Josh Holtz: I, I went to school
for software engineering at the
Milwaukee School of Engineering.
And that whole time I actually
had a corporate internship. So I
was pretty familiar with the
corporate world. And I, I ended
up taking the my, my post grad
job was like a completely
different kind of corporate
field. It was, I was actually, I
took a job that was more like
low level programming, it was
for monitors, or displays that
were going into military
aircraft, and where my
internship was more like high
level Java web services. And I
was like, I want to try
something completely new. I'm
young. Let's try it. Well, the
job I took for the low level
programming, they end up
switching teams on me. And I
ended up going on to a team for
the Blackhawk helicopter that
was in a four year testing
phase. So I, I was just like
checking boxes, testing
monitors, pushing things to see
if things worked. And I'm like,
I'm, I'm over this. So like, I
probably could have changed
teams, but like I already had a
bad taste in my mouth. So I'm
like, I'm out. But then before
college, I also in high school,
I took three years of
programming classes there to
visual basic five, I think,
HTML, JavaScript, and then two
years of Java. Before starting
consulting, I had about seven
years programming experience, or
so
Jeroen Leenarts: you did some
extra courses during your
college education. But what got
you interested into computers
and programming.
Josh Holtz: So my dad is
actually a computer programmer.
He's been a computer programmer
for 35 years now. And I actually
didn't know much about it when
growing up. It didn't really
interest me at all, I was more
interested in like, for a while,
like arts, graphic design kind
of stuff. Accounting. My mom did
accounting on her own when I was
probably like 10 to 14 and
actually helped her out with
some accounting stuff. And
things made sense. Um, like,
maybe I'll do that. But my high
school offered a programming
class and my dad was like, you
know, just try it see how it is
try something new. And like day
one of the class I'm like, this
is this is it like things just
things just clicked and made
sense? It was fun. I I just knew
like that was what I wanted to
do.
Jeroen Leenarts: And you had a
proud that at that point, right?
I did. I did. Yeah. So yeah, I
can imagine that. Not everybody
gets into programming like
because at eight years old, they
are already like, messing away
with bash scripts or a lot of
people that are interviewed were
actually with Commodore and
Amiga OS but that's yeah a
little bit before your time.
Josh Holtz: I think that is all
before my time. Yeah, I did. I
did visual basic five, which I
don't even think that thing
anymore.
Jeroen Leenarts: Now it's got
got replaced by official basic
dotnet I think
Josh Holtz: yeah. Yeah, I don't
think I even touch that one at
all ever.
Jeroen Leenarts: Let's see
Fastlane tools, you're able to
work on that full time. Because
you, is it a sponsorship? Or is
it like a project contribution?
How did that happen? Actually,
Josh Holtz: Google owns
fastline. And I'm currently
being funded through them. I'm
not a Google employee. But they
they sponsored my work full
time.
Jeroen Leenarts: That's really
cool. Yeah. And what are your
plans for Fastlane in the, in
the first half of this year,
Josh Holtz: who so probably
catch up on prs. It's been a
pretty busy December, I've been
super active because I've been
away for a few weeks. But I'm
trying to catch back up on PRs
issues. And then finish off some
of the last tools that are
needed for the App Store connect
migration. There's two major
tools that are still left that
need to get migrate over to the
new API. That would be produce,
which is the one that creates
the app, the developer portal
and the App Store. And then PEM,
which does a lot of the like
push cert stuff. So I think
those are the major tools they
need to get converted over yet.
And there's always things that
need love. For for this past
year, it really hasn't been any
like major new features. Besides
migration. It's just been kind
of catching up on all the
things. Faslane kind of lives in
a weird space. It's an
integration tool. So there's
always things that change that
always need adopting. So even if
I have plans, things usually
like pop up into the top of the
queue pretty quickly. But we
will be supporting Ruby 2.7.
Soon, even though it's been out
for a while, that hasn't been
high, highest in the queue. And
then Ruby 3.0, was announced in
Christmas Day. So there should
be support coming for that as
well. And then we don't really
have a good plan for like
Fastlane 3.0, yet, but we do
want to make some sort of big,
big change, new change coming up
soon since we have been
investing 2.0 for a while, I
don't know what 3.0 is yet,
probably needs some time to
think about where we can take
things. But being full time for
the past six months, it's kind
of helped catch up to where we
can maybe start thinking about
like, changes to the actual like
core itself that can prove it
for a three Oh, release.
Jeroen Leenarts: So and you
mentioned already the the App
Store connect API. So if you
compare the current situation of
the App Store connect API with
what was available previously.
Any thoughts on that?
Josh Holtz: Oh, it's so good.
I'm so happy about it. I was I
was at the WWDC in 2018, where
the App Store connect API was
announced. And I wasn't really
expecting it. And I think I
probably cried when it was
announced, because I'm like this
is this is like the thing we
need. Trying to find all the
private API's and understand
them and like adopt them all the
time. is very time consuming. So
having like an official API that
will stay consistent, that has
information on it, like that's
ideal, I knew was going to be a
very slow change, because
there's a lot of API's that
needed to get written for
Fastlane to fully adopt it. And
the first year 2018, we couldn't
really change much. There was
very, it was very little what
was offered that would have
actually been replaced, like
maybe like 3% of API calls. So
it wasn't really worth 2019
There was a bit more released.
So we started changing over some
tools like pilot, because the
testflight API was announced for
it. And that that helped quite a
bit. And then this past past
year, they announced pretty much
almost all the API's that we
needed. So I think we're
probably at like 90% of the
API's are migrated over to the
official app store connect API.
Which, which is nice because the
official app store connect API
does not need two factor auth,
which causes a huge headache for
C eyes. So and I believe in
February, all accounts are
required to have two FA now. So
having the App Store connect API
available is gonna make it a lot
easier for everyone who's using
it on a CI.
Jeroen Leenarts: Okay. Yeah, of
course, it's now that you you
can configure the App Store
connect API by just extracting a
key from the from the
connectors,
Josh Holtz: rack. Yep. Yep, it
feels it feels a lot more
secure. We never stored any of
the Apple ID information, but it
still always felt weird as a
user and During that, because it
is kind of your personal private
account. So having something
that is a little bit more secure
and revocable feels a lot better
from from our standpoint.
Jeroen Leenarts: And are you the
only person who is fully tasked
with maintaining Fastlane tools?
And is the rest of the
contributions by volunteers?
You're also a volunteer, of
course, but you have some income
from it.
Josh Holtz: Yeah, so I'm the
only full time on it. There is
another guy at Google, who is my
manager, I guess, is what you
would call him. He does more of
like the Google liaison. This
between me and them. And then
everybody else, yeah, is a
volunteer.
Jeroen Leenarts: But, but
looking at your work on Fastlane
tools, you probably learned,
like, a lot of detail about the
App Store connect API.
Josh Holtz: Oh, yeah, I, I know,
I know, probably way too much.
Sometimes I feel like,
Jeroen Leenarts: but yeah, when
did the idea for the Connect kit
app, pop in your mind?
Josh Holtz: Ah, so So Connect
kit. So I've been a fan of the
App Store connect API for what,
like, two, two years now. Like,
it's it's so fun to use. And it
came out of really just wanting
to understand how iOS shortcuts
work. I, I've never, up until
this past year, I knew shortcuts
were a thing in iOS. And I
couldn't figure out a good use
case personally on how I wanted
to use them. So I was like,
Well, I guess that the best way
for me to figure out how I
personally want to use, like
shortcuts in different apps is
to actually make an app that has
shortcuts in it. What can I make
that like is a nice
understanding for me how to like
work through shortcuts. And it
turns out that like I was like,
well, the App Store type API is
something that I already know.
So I don't need to like learn a
new domain, I can just use that.
And then I put a proof of
concept together one night, and
I'm like, Oh, this is actually
like, kind of useful. And it was
just kind of born out of an
experimentation of me wanting to
learn how to do shortcuts.
Jeroen Leenarts: And how's the
app been been doing thus far?
Josh Holtz: It's been doing
pretty good, I think better than
what I expected. It's it's a
super niche app, I guess. Like,
it's for developers, but iOS
developers, but iOS developers
that have access to an app store
connect API, who also loves
shortcuts and automation. So
like, it's a very, like, small
subset of people, I think, who
actually like want to use it or
need to use it. But I'm pretty
happy with with the result. So
far, I mean, couple 1000
downloads, I think I have, like
3000. I didn't, I don't think I
don't think I expected that that
many. Since it is, it's probably
not the best use case for the
App Store connect API. But there
are like a few fun things that
you can do with it. But I'm
still working on adding more
different shortcuts to it. To
make things easier, so like,
right now you there are, there's
a shortcut that's like a generic
HTTP request to one. Or if you
read the App Store type API
docs, you can do any request you
want. But that requires reading
the docs quite a bit. But we
have actions for like viewing
all all apps, getting finance
reports, I'm going to create an
action that actually likes that,
that submits an app to the App
Store, select which one, which
IPA you want to use. So kind of
like what Fast Lane kind of
groups together, I'm going to
create a few of those specialty
ones to make automation easier
on users. So they don't have to
know as much about the API, but
can still use it.
Jeroen Leenarts: And what are
typical things that you hear
people are doing with the
Connect app.
Josh Holtz: A lot of people I
think are using the finance and
sales reports, and then
displaying that in charts, or I
don't know what else you do with
it. But I mean, I don't really
have too many sales. So I don't
really have too many use cases
for myself on that. But that is
something that you can do. I
think people are using it for
testing for test flight too. I
do have a sample shortcut in
there that you can add user to a
test flight group. And you can
either enter an email address in
a text field or select from a
contact. So it actually makes
adding in like a one off tester
really easy. And I think
probably either I think probably
like this, the sales, the sales
reports, finance reports. And
the test flight stuff is
probably the things that are
going to get used the most. But
yeah, you can you can submit a
build with it. If you want, you
can select a build. I found a
pretty good use case for
submitting a build. I would test
my test flight build on my
phone. And then once I'm happy
with it, I just run a shortcut
to submit the app
Jeroen Leenarts: It takes the
latest upload for a specific
version and then pushes it into
review completely or just select
it in the
Josh Holtz: it, it might
shortcut selects the latest
binary. And then and then
submits that for review. I
already had the change log added
in there from my, from my upload
script. But I'm thinking of
adding a change log shortcut
action in there too, so that I
can update the change log if I
want from that action, which
might be a pain if it's a really
big change log to type on my
phone. But at least I have an
option to do that too.
Jeroen Leenarts: But connected
is not the only thing that you
that you work on. Because I also
know that you do in the Deaf
Monday. That's a newsletter if
I'm correct, right?
Josh Holtz: Correct. Yes, I
started that one and June of
2020, I think.
Jeroen Leenarts: And why did you
start a newsletter?
Josh Holtz: I was talking with
him. I think it was in May, I
was talking with Charlie Chapman
and Christian Seelig. I don't
know how we got on this topic,
but they were both doing
something. And I think it was
like Monday, July, June 20 22nd,
or something like that. It was
Christian's birthday. And each
year for Apollo, he does like a
special like, Animal Rescue
donation kind of thing. So he
was like, preparing for that.
And then Charlie Chaplin was
releasing dark noise 2.0 On the
same day. So it was a really fun
day on Twitter, because there
was so much action from both of
both of their big events. And I
tweeted out, I was like, I want
this, like, indie dev
excitement, every week. And
like, 10 minutes after I tweet
that I'm like, Well, I mean, I
guess I could actually make that
happen by like, featuring a new
developer every week, them their
app, their story. And I, in in
the next 24 hours, I quickly
created the site newsletter, and
all that stuff, because I knew
if I didn't do it in those 24
hours, I probably would not have
actually committed to it. So I
got, I got, I got everything up
and ready by Wednesday. And I
found my first two developers
who thankfully answered my
questions, I think within 48
hours, so that I could have it
for the next for the next week.
And that's kind of how kind of
how it started, was just from an
exciting day on Twitter, about
indie developers, and kind of
continuing that on through the
rest of the year.
Jeroen Leenarts: So and how's
the newsletter been doing? As
far as it is being read?
Josh Holtz: Yeah. So the, the,
the actual like newsletter,
email subscribers is, I think
less than what, what I thought
was going to happen or it's
growing at a smaller rate. But
the Twitter following is
actually growing a lot more. And
the thing I don't actually know
how to manage it, or to see is
RSS subscriptions. Because I
don't, I don't know how people
can see like, who's subscribing
from there. But there actually
is a pretty good following on on
Twitter, I probably could be
marketing the email portion of
the newsletter a lot more. But
that's not not really my
specialty. So part of my goal of
of this year is to try and grow
the email portion a little bit
more. But also, the newsletter
might be harder to read an email
versus on web, because it is
kind of kind of a long
newsletter. So I don't know what
what medium people prefer to
read it in. I prefer to read it
on the web. But I think between
all three of those, it seems
like it's growing pretty well.
And I've, I've had a lot of fun
doing it, which is the most
important part. I've met a lot
of cool people. And I had a year
in review blog post that was
published last Monday. And over,
over those last few months, I've
interviewed 39 developers from
19 countries, which is kind of
crazy to think about. And my my
goal for this year is to try and
get more country representation
than I have right now. It turns
out that a lot of indies are
from Europe, at least the ones
that I am networked with some
trying to grow, grow my network
outside of Europe, even though
Europe is super cool. So I have
I have some that are lined up
from Africa right now. I think I
got a Mexico one lined up. Just
trying to try to get more
diverse throughout 2021.
Jeroen Leenarts: It's actually
interesting goal for 2021
Because I remember that you also
had a goal for yourself for 2025
Josh Holtz: Next. Yes, my goal
for 2020 was to do conference
speaking if that's the one
you're talking about. Yeah.
Jeroen Leenarts: So how did that
work out for you?
Josh Holtz: I mean, I didn't
leave my house in 2020. So that
that kind of made that a little
bit hard. I did have a few
conferences lined up. But I
mean, everything kind of got
postponed or cancelled because
of pandemic. But I don't know if
any Monday would really have
been a thing. If, if, if the
pandemic wasn't here, because my
goal probably would have been
more like outside of Twitter and
more on speaking in real world.
But going into, I guess,
whenever it's safe for us to
leave the house again and meet
up in real life, I still want to
accomplish that, that that same.
Same kind of code of speaking.
Jeroen Leenarts: Yeah. So and
but why did you put yourself up
to the task of doing a lot of
conference talks in 2020?
Because I know you had a very
personal goal to actually do
that.
Josh Holtz: Yes. So I've had a
stutter, since I think since
like, first grade, at least,
that's as early as I can
remember it. And a lot of people
don't actually know I, I have
one, I don't have the worst kind
of stutter that's out there. So
I'm thankful for that. I can be
fluid most of the time. It does
really show itself when I I
don't have like different
options of words to speak. So
example is saying my name is
really hard for me. Because I
don't really have another name
for myself. So introductions are
hard ordering food is hard.
Sometimes.
Jeroen Leenarts: It's the very
specifically that if you have a
couple of synonyms for a word,
that it's easier for you then
write a single words, that's
actually describe what you want
to say. Correct? Yeah,
Josh Holtz: yeah. Cuz like, the
more the more, the more I fail
on a word, the, the more I fail
on a word. So like, it just kind
of snowballs. And I'm pretty
sure a majority of it is a
mental thing. I mean, I don't
actually know how it works. But
I've, I've tried to deal with
the best I can. And kind of like
use it to be more of like, a
strength than anything. Because
I have a, I have a hard time
always saying what I want, I try
and listen more to what others
have to say. So that I kind of
try and use it to my advantage
in that sense. But speaking at
conferences is a is a little
different. Because I I mean, I
think when most people prepare
for a conference talk, they
actually like plan out exactly
word for what they're gonna say.
And I don't I kind of I kind of
wing all the talks that I've
done so far. Because it ends up
being a bit better I, I do I do
plan out like what each slide is
going to be. But I don't
actually think about what what
words I'm going to say because
that just kind of ruins things
for me. But I have realized that
if I tell people I do have a
stutter in the beginning of my
talk. So which is usually like
slide three, I end up having a
little bit better luck being
more fluent. Just because people
like know what to expect. versus
me just kind of like stuttering
are nowhere and then then being
confused.
Jeroen Leenarts: It's
interesting how you can actually
come to grips with with Yeah,
something that is hard for you.
And then yeah, being able to
just make it the strength of
your personality, actually,
which is really cool, I must
say. So yeah, you were of course
unable to do the full goal for
all of 2020. Yes. But how many
talks were you able to pull off
in, in the last year?
Josh Holtz: So I did quite a few
virtually the Koko heads
Netherlands was the first one,
which was I think, I think that
was April. And now when I did a
demo of fastline. Hard to say
sometimes. So that one, that one
was super fun, because I gave
myself a 40 minute time limit of
implementing it from nothing to
App Store. And I want to say it
was pretty successful. I think I
only had like one issue during
that. During that were I think
them messed up or something. I
think that was at meetup that
would have been something else
where something messed up but
end up being successful. I think
what the video has like 7000
views at the moment.
Jeroen Leenarts: I think it's
doing good actually. Yeah.
Josh Holtz: Which is pretty
crazy to think about. That was
my first one and I did another
talk at a Koko heads meetup for
Sydney. That one I recorded
ahead of time because of major
timezone differences. And that
one was on App Store connect
API. And then I did quite a few
pods. I did three different
podcasts as well throughout the
year. Which the first one was
really scary because it is all
all speaking But they've gotten,
I think they've gotten
progressively easier. But also,
still a little spooky at times,
Jeroen Leenarts: I can imagine.
Because if it's not your natural
strength, then everything is
scary. But if it's like, correct
like this, there's not much you
can do to prepare Actually, no,
no, no, no. And that's also the
I cannot imagine because I don't
have a stutter myself. But I can
imagine that it is, it can be
very annoying, because you're
perfectly prepared, you know
what you want to say. And then I
just stuff just doesn't come
out. And you need to really
force that word up. Because, for
instance, Fastlane, that's just
a product name. And because it's
a product name, there is no
other name for it. So yeah,
yeah, I have to say that once I
have to say words, yeah. It's
Are there any books or resources
that you think that people
should really be aware of? Or
that you think you should
definitely read or listen or
whatever consume that?
Josh Holtz: I've been trying to
read Danny's practical combine.
And he is just released
practical core data. I think
that was officially released
today. The whole thing. So I've,
those are probably ones that I
would recommend. I can't say
that I've fully read either of
them yet, because my time has
been a little bit busy the past
month. But those resources seem
pretty great. And really useful
for most apps these days.
Jeroen Leenarts: Yeah, yeah.
Make sure to link those from the
show notes as well. Are there
any other places online that
people can learn about you or
read stuff that you publish?
Josh Holtz: I got so Josh, he
holds on Twitter. Josh, he holds
on GitHub, if you'd like to look
through my GitHub activity. I
don't know people actually do
that. Josh, he holds on
Instagram, which I occasionally
post cat photos, dog photos,
baby photos, rock climbing
photos, that's not not super
active these days on Instagram,
but they're there. And then Josh
Holt's dot com, where I have my
blog, which I'm trying to
somewhat be more active on, but
that's not my top priority.
Jeroen Leenarts: But everything,
but everything else you are
online is linked from Josh
volts.com or
Josh Holtz: correct, yes. Yep.
And I think everything is also
linked from my Twitter bio.
Jeroen Leenarts: Josh, thanks
for your time.
Josh Holtz: And thanks for
having me.
Jeroen Leenarts: It's been fun.
I will talk to you hopefully
sometime in person in the in the
new year. And so hope so. Yeah.
Thank you for your time.
Josh Holtz: Thank you very much.